Court Shoots Down Ban On Homeless Living In Vehicles - Los Angeles News | FOX 11 LA KTTV

Court Shoots Down Ban On Homeless Living In Vehicles

Posted: Updated:
Los Angeles, CA -

(FOX 11 / CNS) A federal appeals court panel struck down Los Angeles' ban on using parked vehicles as "living quarters" today, ruling that the law is unconstitutional because it discriminates against the homeless and impoverished.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in Pasadena unanimously ruled that the city's 1983 ordinance, which bans people from living in cars or recreational vehicles on city streets or in parking lots, is unconstitutionally vague and "criminalizes innocent behavior."

"This broad and cryptic statute criminalizes innocent behavior, making it impossible for citizens to know how to keep their conduct within the pale," Judge Harry Pregerson wrote for the court.

A group of homeless car dwellers sued the city in 2011 but lost in Los Angeles federal court, leading to the appeal.

The Los Angeles law prohibits the use of vehicles as living quarters both overnight and "day-by-day, or otherwise."

A representative for the City Attorney's Office did not immediately respond to a request for comment. In overturning the lower court, the appeals panel said the law had caused "arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement."

Pregerson wrote that the statute is so vague that it could "cover any driver in Los Angeles who eats food or transports personal belongings in his or her vehicle," but it "appears to be applied only to the homeless."

When Los Angeles police began aggressively enforcing the ban in 2010 after complaints from Venice residents, city officials said the law was designed to protect health and safety.

However, the appeals court determined that "arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement is exactly what has occurred here," according to the ruling.

Update From Gigi Graciette:

A Quote from Los Angeles City Attorney Mike Feuer.

"In the wake of the Court’s ruling yesterday, I will work with other City leaders to craft a constitutional ordinance that respects both the rights and needs of homeless individuals and protects the quality of life in our neighborhoods. I believe this approach is much more constructive than continuing to litigate the legality of the old ordinance."

More broadly, the persistence of homelessness continues to disgrace not only our City, but our region and our country as a whole. We need to make a break from the past, recognize that the civil and criminal justice systems alone can’t effectively address homelessness, and commit ourselves to grappling with the issues that create homelessness in the first place. We’ve only begun to make strides in that direction, and it will take collective leadership to make meaningful progress.

Frank T. Mateljan III
Deputy Director
Community Engagement and Outreach
Los Angeles City Attorney's Office
Phone: (213) 978-8340

Powered by WorldNow

1999 S. Bundy Dr.
Los Angeles CA 90025

Main: (310) 584-2000
News Tips? (310) 584-2025

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices